If we are going to end this era of dysfunctional government, we somehow have to restore trust in government. One can’t blame the voters for not trusting government if they don’t feel they can trust the election process. There are some in the media who are trying to scare people into thinking the 2008 MN governor election was a fraud and that it is happening again. State GOP leader Tony Sutton says “something smells" and “we won’t get rolled this time.” Fox 9 TV anchor Heidi Collins suggests something is fishy because the Sec of State office was prepared for a recount and asks Secretary of State, Mark Ritchie, "why is it happening here again?" Rush Limbaugh compares the 2008 Franken-Coleman recount to the corrupt elections in Iran. Bill O’Reilly claims “the fix is in” referring to the 2008 recount. Finally, around noon on Election Day of 2010, the Republican Party lawyer sends out press releases to local papers questioning the integrity of the election.
As the process is coming to a close, it might surprise you to hear what some of the key people involved in the 2008 recount had to say.
Fritz Knaack, Attorney for Norm Coleman, on Almanac, “There was a lot of criticism and a lot of suspicion, let’s say, that was generated in the senate race, the fact of the matter is… we were looking for fraud and we didn’t see it. 2/5/10
Joe Friedberg, attorney for Norm Coleman, said before MN Supreme Court, 6/1/09 “There was no election fraud. There was no voter fraud.”
Jim Langdon, Attorney for Norm Coleman, in response to a question from Justice Paul Anderson, 2/12/09: “Not a whiff of fraud.”
Two different courts ruled unanimously on most of the major decisions concerning the recount.
The first court released a statement “After seven weeks of trial, the factual record is devoid of any allegations of fraud, tampering, or security breaches on Election Day, during the recount process, or during the election contest”
MN Supreme Court Chief Justice Eric Magnuson (appointed by Tim Pawlenty) stated, “it was an open and transparent process. That openness worked spectacularly well and helped promote whatever trust there was in the highly scrutinized process.”
Former Republican Sec of State Mary Kiffmeyer, stated in 2006, “No other state in the country has gone to that degree of security in regards to the ballots, source code and checking it afterwards. It’s a great place to be in. Minnesota can really be proud.”
MN has 30,000 election workers, several thousand voting machines, and more than 2 million voters. It is inevitable there will be some machine malfunction - that is why we have a paper trail of every vote cast. Minnesota Majority says there have been “over 40 convictions of voter fraud stemming from the 2008 elections.” Virtually all of these are individual cases of a convicted felon voting while still on probation. This is hardly the kind of systemic fraud that FOX News and others are saying stole the election. The Minnesota courts agreed.
Tony Sutton talked about a smell test in reference to the fact that Republicans did so well in the State but did not win the Governors race. WCCO TV did a Reality Check and found that in 2006, DFL candidate Amy Klobuchar won the Senate by 20% points, yet Tim Pawlenty won the Governors race. In 2008 Barack Obama won the vote in MN by 10% and DFL candidate Franken won by only .01%. The lesson: Minnesotans do not always vote a straight ticket.
According to Wabasha County officials, the election in Wabasha County went very smoothly, despite some of the rumors floating around.
It is not easy to discern the truth in the media frenzy surrounding us today. At some point people have to take personal responsibility to seek out the truth. In this case, ask yourself who can I believe: the attorneys who argued the case for both sides, the two courts that listened to all the evidence, and Gov Pawlenty who certified the election, OR do I believe Rush Limbaugh, Fox News, Bill O’Reilly and Tony Sutton? With the growing popularity of cable news, talk radio, and the internet over recent years, we've seen that if something is repeated enough, by different people, and in different media, many people assume that it must be true. Hopefully people will come to the realization that repetition does not equal truth. It may be best to just “turn them off”.
